Pension Lump Sum vs. Monthly Annuity: A Framework for Deciding
Take the lump sum or keep the pension? Learn how discount rates, life expectancy, inflation risk, and personal circumstances shape this high-stakes decision.
A pension is a promise. A lump sum is a possibility. The right choice depends on which risk you'd rather carry.
— FinanceWonk
A pension lump sum is a one-time payment offered by some employers as an alternative to receiving monthly pension checks for life. It represents the present value of your future pension payments, calculated using IRS-mandated interest rates and mortality tables.
Key Takeaways
This decision is permanent and irreversible. Once you take the lump sum, you cannot change your mind. The monthly pension option disappears forever, making this one of the highest-stakes financial choices you’ll face.
Your pension has a hidden “interest rate” built in. The lump sum offer implies a rate of return—typically 5-7%. If you can consistently beat that rate investing on your own, the lump sum may come out ahead. If not, the pension likely wins.
Longevity is the central variable in this equation. Pensions reward those who live longer. If you have health concerns or shorter family longevity, the lump sum may be more valuable. If you’re likely to live into your 90s, the pension often wins.
Most pensions lose purchasing power over time. Without a cost-of-living adjustment (COLA), a fixed $2,500/month pension will buy roughly $1,500 worth of goods in 20 years at 3% inflation. Factor this erosion into your comparison.
5-7%
Typical Implicit Rate
80-85
Break-even Age Range
45%
Purchasing Power Lost (20 yrs, 3% inflation)
$300K-$500K
Median Lump Sum Offer
What Is It — Two Ways to Take Your Pension Benefit
Think of a pension lump sum decision as being offered two different lottery tickets. One ticket pays you a fixed amount every month for as long as you live—whether that’s 15 years or 35 years. The other ticket hands you a large pile of cash today, but now you’re responsible for making it last. The pension is betting you won’t live long enough to collect more than the lump sum is worth. You’re betting you will.
How Lump Sums Are Calculated
Your employer doesn’t pull the lump sum number out of thin air. They calculate the present value of all your expected future pension payments using two key inputs: how long you’re statistically expected to live (mortality tables) and what interest rate to use for discounting future payments back to today’s dollars.
The IRS mandates specific interest rates for this calculation, called 417(e) segment rates. These rates change monthly and directly affect your lump sum offer. When rates are low, lump sums are higher (future payments are worth more today). When rates rise, lump sums shrink. This is why timing can matter—the same pension benefit might produce a $500,000 lump sum in one interest rate environment and $420,000 in another.
Why Interest Rates Matter So Much
From 2021 to 2023, rising interest rates caused many pension lump sums to drop 15-25%. A retiree who delayed their decision by 18 months might have seen their offer fall from $480,000 to $380,000—a $100,000 difference for the same monthly benefit.
Two Fundamentally Different Retirement Strategies
Choosing between the pension and lump sum isn’t just a math problem—it’s a choice between two philosophies of retirement security. The pension prioritizes guaranteed income and simplicity. The lump sum prioritizes control and flexibility.
The Monthly Pension
Predictable income that arrives every month regardless of market conditions. You never have to worry about outliving your money or making investment decisions.
- • Guaranteed for life (and possibly your spouse’s life)
- • No investment management required
- • Protected from market crashes
- • Cannot be accessed as a lump sum for emergencies
- • Typically no inflation adjustment
- • Dies with you (no inheritance value)
The Lump Sum
Full control over a large sum of money. You decide how to invest it, when to withdraw, and what happens to any remainder when you die.
- • Complete flexibility in withdrawals
- • Potential for growth that outpaces inflation
- • Can leave remainder to heirs
- • Available for large expenses or emergencies
- • Market risk falls entirely on you
- • Requires active management or advisor fees
The Hidden Bet You’re Making
Every pension lump sum offer contains an implicit assumption: that you’ll live to approximately your actuarial life expectancy. For a 65-year-old, that’s roughly age 84-86 depending on gender. If you live exactly that long, the pension and lump sum (invested at the implicit rate) end up roughly equal.
But you won’t live exactly to your life expectancy—you’ll live longer or shorter. If you pass away at 72, the pension company wins: they paid out far less than the lump sum was worth. If you live to 95, you win: you’ve collected far more than the lump sum could have generated. This is the bet at the heart of the decision.
The Survivor Benefit Question
If you’re married, your pension likely offers a survivor benefit—a reduced monthly payment that continues to your spouse after you die. This benefit has real value, often equivalent to $50,000-$150,000 of life insurance. If you take the lump sum, you’re giving up this protection unless you purchase equivalent coverage separately.
How It Works — Discount Rates, Life Expectancy, and the Math
The pension vs. lump sum decision ultimately comes down to three numbers: the implicit rate of return embedded in your pension, the investment return you can realistically achieve, and how long you expect to live. Let’s work through the math.
Finding Your Pension’s Implicit Rate
Your pension’s implicit rate of return is the investment return you’d need to earn on the lump sum to replicate your pension income for life. Think of it as the hurdle rate you must clear for the lump sum to be the better choice.
The Core Question
At what investment return would the lump sum, withdrawn at the pension’s monthly rate, last exactly as long as you live?
If Lump Sum = $450,000 and Monthly Pension = $2,500
Then Annual Withdrawal = $30,000 (6.67% of lump sum)
The implicit rate is the return needed to sustain this withdrawal rate for your expected lifespan without depleting principal prematurely.
For a typical pension offer, the implicit rate falls between 5% and 7%. This rate is influenced by the IRS segment rates used in the calculation and the mortality assumptions. A “generous” lump sum offer has a lower implicit rate (easier to beat); a “stingy” offer has a higher one.
Break-Even Age: When the Pension Catches Up
The break-even age is when the total value of pension payments received equals what the lump sum would have grown to. Live past this age, and the pension wins. Die before it, and the lump sum would have been better (at least financially).
| Investment Return Assumed | Break-Even Age (Male) | Break-Even Age (Female) |
|---|---|---|
| 4% | 88 | 91 |
| 5% | 85 | 88 |
| 6% | 82 | 85 |
| 7% | 80 | 82 |
| 8% | 78 | 80 |
*Based on $2,500/month pension vs. $450,000 lump sum for a 65-year-old retiree. Assumes lump sum withdrawals match pension amount. Women have higher break-even ages due to longer average life expectancy.
Practical Takeaway
At a 6% return assumption, a 65-year-old man breaks even around age 82-83. Given that roughly 40% of 65-year-old men will live past 85, the pension has favorable odds for those in good health. The higher the return you assume you can earn, the younger the break-even age—but higher returns require more risk.
A Tale of Two Retirees
Let’s see how this plays out for two different people facing the same offer: a $2,500/month pension or a $450,000 lump sum.
Margaret: The Pension Taker
- • Both parents lived past 90
- • Excellent health, walks 3 miles daily
- • Nervous about stock market volatility
- • Has modest 401(k) for flexibility
- • Values predictable monthly income
If Margaret lives to 92:
$810,000
Total pension payments received (27 years × $30,000)
Robert: The Lump Sum Taker
- • Father died at 68, mother at 74
- • Type 2 diabetes, managed with medication
- • Experienced investor, comfortable with markets
- • Wants to leave inheritance to grandchildren
- • Has rental property for base income
If Robert passes at 78 with 6% returns:
$285,000
Remaining balance to heirs (after 13 years of $30K/yr withdrawals)
Neither choice is universally “right.” Margaret’s pension pays out nearly twice the lump sum if she lives long. Robert’s lump sum preserves wealth for heirs and gives him flexibility, which matters more given his health outlook. The same offer, two completely rational but opposite decisions.
The Inflation Factor Most People Ignore
Most pensions don’t include cost-of-living adjustments. That $2,500/month that feels comfortable at 65 buys less every year. Here’s what happens to purchasing power over time:
| Time Period | Nominal Payment | Purchasing Power (3% inflation) |
|---|---|---|
| Year 1 | $2,500 | $2,500 |
| Year 10 | $2,500 | $1,860 |
| Year 20 | $2,500 | $1,385 |
| Year 25 | $2,500 | $1,195 |
| Year 30 | $2,500 | $1,030 |
*Shows how $2,500/month loses buying power at 3% annual inflation. By year 30, your pension buys what $1,030 would buy today.
The Inflation Reality Check
A lump sum invested in a diversified portfolio has historically grown faster than inflation, potentially preserving or increasing purchasing power. A fixed pension does not. Over a 25-year retirement, this difference can be dramatic—the pension’s “guaranteed” income becomes a guarantee of declining living standards.
The Rollover Rule: Avoiding the Tax Trap
If you take the lump sum, how you receive it matters enormously. A direct rollover to an IRA preserves the tax-deferred status—no taxes owed until you withdraw. If instead the check is made out to you, 20% is withheld for taxes immediately, and you have just 60 days to deposit the full amount (including the withheld 20% from other funds) into an IRA to avoid owing taxes and potential penalties on the entire sum.
Rule of Thumb
Always request a direct rollover (also called a “trustee-to-trustee transfer”). The check should be made payable to your IRA custodian, not to you. This single step can save $50,000-$100,000 or more in unnecessary taxes on a typical lump sum.
What It Means for You — A Framework for Your Decision
There’s no universally correct answer to the pension vs. lump sum question. The right choice depends on factors unique to your situation. Here are the four levers that matter most.
The Four Factors That Drive Your Decision
1. Health & Family Longevity
Your personal health status and family history are the strongest predictors of which option wins financially. If your parents and grandparents routinely lived into their 90s and you're in good health, the pension has better odds. If longevity isn't in your family or you have serious health conditions, the lump sum's certainty becomes more valuable.
2. Other Guaranteed Income
How much guaranteed income will you already have? Add up Social Security, your spouse's pension, annuity payments, or rental income. If these cover your essential expenses, you have more flexibility to take investment risk with the lump sum. If the pension would be your primary guaranteed income source, its security carries more weight.
3. Investment Skill & Risk Tolerance
Be honest: will you actually invest the lump sum wisely, or might you panic-sell in a downturn? The implicit rate you need to beat (typically 5-7%) is achievable with a balanced portfolio over the long term, but only if you stay the course. If market volatility keeps you up at night, the pension's guarantees may be worth more to you than the math suggests.
4. Flexibility vs. Security
Do you value having options, or do you value predictability? The lump sum lets you adjust withdrawals, access large sums for emergencies or opportunities, and leave money to heirs. The pension lets you stop thinking about it entirely. Neither is wrong—but knowing which you truly value helps clarify the decision.
Reality Check: The Pension Company Isn’t Stupid
Here’s an uncomfortable truth: pension plans employ teams of actuaries whose job is to ensure the lump sum offer is fair—to the pension fund. The offer is calculated to be roughly equivalent in expected value to the monthly pension for someone of average health and longevity. They’re not offering you a windfall; they’re offering you a trade.
This means the lump sum is neither a “great deal” nor a “bad deal” in the abstract. It’s a neutral exchange—unless your personal circumstances differ from the average. If you’re healthier than average, the pension is likely better for you. If you’re less healthy than average, the lump sum probably is.
Pro Tip
Before deciding, calculate your “personal break-even age” and compare it to your realistic life expectancy. If break-even is 83 and three of your four grandparents lived past 90, the pension looks attractive. If break-even is 83 and you’ve already had a heart attack, the math tilts toward the lump sum.
What If You’re Not Sure About Your Longevity?
Most people underestimate how long they’ll live. If you’re a healthy 65-year-old, there’s roughly a 25% chance you’ll live past 90. The question isn’t “how long will I live?” but “how long might I live?” The pension protects against the “risk” of living a very long time—which is actually a wonderful outcome, just an expensive one to fund.
If you genuinely can’t assess your longevity odds, consider this: the pension is the conservative choice. You can’t outlive it. The lump sum is the aggressive choice—potentially better, but with more ways to go wrong (poor investment returns, overspending, or simply living longer than expected).
What If You Have a Spouse?
Marriage complicates the decision in important ways. Most pensions offer survivor benefits—a reduced monthly payment (often 50-75% of the original) that continues to your spouse after you die. If your spouse is likely to outlive you by many years, this benefit has substantial value.
With the lump sum, you control what happens to remaining funds. But you also bear the risk of depleting them before your spouse passes. If you take the lump sum and die early after a market downturn, your spouse could be left with far less than the survivor pension would have provided.
The Spousal Consideration
If your spouse is significantly younger, in better health, or would struggle to manage investments on their own, the pension’s survivor benefit becomes more valuable. Run the numbers on what income your spouse would have under each scenario—not just while you’re alive, but after.
The Bottom Line
Take the pension if: you’re in good health with family longevity, you value guaranteed income over flexibility, you lack other reliable income sources, or you’re uncomfortable managing investments. Take the lump sum if: you have health concerns or shorter family longevity, you have substantial other guaranteed income, you’re a confident investor who won’t panic-sell, or leaving money to heirs is a priority. When in doubt, the pension is the safer choice—you cannot outlive it.
Try It Out — Compare Your Options Side by Side
Ready to analyze your specific pension offer? Enter your numbers below to see your pension’s implicit rate of return, your personal break-even age, and how inflation will affect your pension’s purchasing power over time. The calculator will help you compare both options using your actual figures.
Quick Start Calculator
Higher Present Value
Pension
by $168,722 in present value
Pension Present Value
$668,722
Lump Sum After 25yr
$153,503
Breakeven Return
5.26%
to last 25 years
Pension vs. Lump Sum Over Retirement
Cumulative pension payments compared to the projected lump sum portfolio balance over time.
What to Look For in the Results
Pension's Implicit Rate of Return
This is the investment return you'd need to earn on the lump sum to replicate your pension income. If this rate is higher than you could realistically achieve (typically above 6-7%), the pension is likely the better deal.
Break-Even Age
The age at which total pension payments equal the lump sum's projected value. Compare this to your realistic life expectancy—if you expect to live well past break-even, the pension wins; if not, the lump sum may be better.
Required Rate to Match Pension
Shows what annual return the lump sum would need to generate to equal the pension's total payments through your expected lifespan. A required rate above 7% is aggressive; below 5% is conservative.
Inflation-Adjusted Pension Value
Shows your pension's purchasing power over time in today's dollars. Watch how a fixed payment erodes—this helps you understand whether the lump sum's growth potential matters for your timeline.
This calculator provides estimates for educational purposes and should not be considered financial advice. Pension decisions are complex and often irreversible—we strongly recommend consulting with a fee-only fiduciary financial advisor before making your final choice. Your specific pension plan may have terms, survivor options, or COLA provisions that affect the analysis.
Run the Full Analysis
The interactive calculator above is a quick-start version. The full tool offers more inputs, detailed breakdowns, data tables, and CSV export.
Open Full Calculator