Renting vs. Buying: The Math Behind the Decision
The rent-vs-buy decision involves more than monthly payments. Learn how to compare the true total cost of each path including opportunity costs, tax benefits, and lifestyle factors.
The question isn't whether to rent or buy — it's which decision costs less over the timeline you actually have.
— FinanceWonk
Rent vs. buy analysis is a financial comparison of the total costs and wealth outcomes of renting a home versus purchasing one over a specific time horizon. It accounts for all costs on both sides—not just the monthly payment—including opportunity costs, transaction fees, and investment returns on capital.
Key Takeaways
1. Time horizon is the deciding factor. The longer you stay, the more buying tends to win. The shorter your stay, the more renting makes financial sense—typically, buying requires 5+ years to break even.
2. Transaction costs are the hidden dealbreaker. Buying and selling a home costs 8-12% of its value in fees. This upfront penalty means short-term owners often lose money even in rising markets.
3. Your down payment has an opportunity cost. That $70,000 down payment could grow to $98,000 in 7 years if invested at 5% real returns. A fair comparison must account for what you give up.
4. "Building equity" isn’t free money. Early mortgage payments are mostly interest, maintenance runs 1-2% of home value annually, and you only capture equity when you sell—minus those transaction costs.
5-7 years
Typical break-even period
8-12%
Transaction costs (buy + sell)
1-2%
Annual maintenance costs
$417,000
Median U.S. home price (2024)
What Is It — Two Paths, Different Hidden Costs
Think of the rent vs. buy decision like choosing between two different travel passes. Renting is like a flexible transit card—you pay as you go, can switch routes easily, and never worry about vehicle maintenance. Buying is like purchasing a car—it requires a large upfront payment, ongoing maintenance, and commitment to a particular vehicle, but after years of payments, you own something. The question isn’t which pass is “better”—it’s which one makes sense for your journey.
The Myth of “Throwing Money Away”
The most persistent myth in personal finance is that rent is “throwing money away” while mortgage payments “build equity.” This framing ignores a crucial reality: homeowners also throw away money—on interest, taxes, insurance, maintenance, and transaction costs. The real question is which path costs more over your actual timeline.
When you pay $2,000 in rent, 100% of it goes to your landlord. But when you pay $2,000 on a mortgage, only a fraction builds equity—especially in the early years. On a typical 30-year mortgage at 7%, your first payment might split $1,400 to interest and just $600 to principal. Add property taxes, insurance, and maintenance, and a homeowner might “throw away” more per month than a renter, at least initially.
The True Cost of Renting
Renting costs include more than your monthly check to the landlord.
- • Monthly rent (increases ~3-5% annually)
- • Renter’s insurance (~$15-30/month)
- • Opportunity cost of not building equity
- • But: Down payment stays invested and growing
The True Cost of Buying
Ownership comes with costs that don’t build equity.
- • Mortgage interest (majority of early payments)
- • Property taxes (~1-2% of home value/year)
- • Homeowner’s insurance (~$150-300/month)
- • Maintenance (~1-2% of home value/year)
- • Transaction costs (8-12% to buy and sell)
- • Opportunity cost of down payment not invested
Why Time Changes Everything
In year one, a buyer faces massive headwinds: closing costs (2-5% of purchase price), mostly-interest mortgage payments, and the opportunity cost of a large down payment. A renter, meanwhile, has lower monthly costs and a growing investment portfolio.
But the math shifts over time. Rent typically increases 3-5% annually, while a fixed-rate mortgage payment stays constant. Home values (historically) appreciate 3-4% per year on average. And each mortgage payment builds slightly more equity than the last as amortization shifts from interest toward principal.
The crossover point—where buying’s advantages finally overcome its upfront costs—typically falls somewhere between 5 and 7 years. Stay shorter, and you likely lose money buying. Stay longer, and ownership usually wins.
The Assumption Trap
Every rent vs. buy calculation depends heavily on assumptions about future home appreciation, rent increases, and investment returns. Small changes to these assumptions can flip the result entirely. The “obvious” choice often isn’t obvious at all—which is exactly why running the numbers for your specific situation matters so much.
The Flexibility Factor
Beyond the pure math, renting buys you optionality. A renter can take a job across the country with 30 days’ notice. A homeowner faces months of listing, showing, negotiating, and closing—plus $30,000-50,000 in transaction costs on a typical home. If your career is mobile, your relationship status is uncertain, or you’re still figuring out where you want to live, that flexibility has real economic value.
The Local Market Matters
Rent vs. buy math varies dramatically by location. In San Francisco or New York, the price-to-rent ratio is so high that renting often wins even over 10+ year horizons. In cities like Dallas or Phoenix, relatively low prices and strong appreciation can make buying attractive in just 3-4 years. Always run the calculation with your local numbers.
How It Works — Comparing Total Cost of Each Path
Let’s walk through a complete comparison using realistic numbers. We’ll compare renting at $2,000/month against buying a $350,000 home, tracking every cost over 7 years to see which path builds more wealth.
Scenario Assumptions
Rent path:
- • Starting rent: $2,000/month
- • Annual rent increase: 3%
- • Renter’s insurance: $30/month
- • Down payment invested at 5% real return
Buy path:
- • Home price: $350,000
- • Down payment: 20% ($70,000)
- • Mortgage: 30-year fixed at 7%
- • Home appreciation: 3%/year
- • Property tax: 1.4%/year
- • Maintenance: 1.5%/year
The Complete 7-Year Comparison
This table tracks every dollar on both paths. The bottom line shows “net wealth impact”—how much poorer each choice makes you over 7 years. (Both paths cost money; the question is which costs less.)
| Cost Category | Rent Path | Buy Path |
|---|---|---|
| Down payment opportunity cost | $0 | $21,743 |
| Monthly payments (total) | $182,573 | $175,392 |
| Property taxes | $0 | $34,300 |
| Insurance | $2,520 | $17,640 |
| Maintenance | $0 | $36,750 |
| Closing costs (buy) | $0 | $10,500 |
| Selling costs (6%) | $0 | $25,452 |
| Total costs paid out | $185,093 | $321,777 |
| Equity built | $0 | $127,030 |
| Home appreciation captured | $0 | $74,200 |
| Net wealth impact | −$185,093 | −$120,547 |
*Assumes 5% real investment return for down payment, 3% annual home appreciation, 3% annual rent increases. Selling costs estimated at 6% of final home value ($424,200).
In this scenario, buying wins by about $64,500 over 7 years. But notice how close it is—and how many assumptions drive that result. Change home appreciation from 3% to 2%, and the gap shrinks to under $30,000. Drop it to 1%, and renting wins.
Practical Takeaway
At 7 years with 3% appreciation, buying slightly wins. But the margin is thin enough that non-financial factors—flexibility, maintenance hassle, neighborhood stability—could reasonably tip the decision either way.
The Break-Even Timeline
The single most important variable in rent vs. buy is how long you stay. This table shows how the break-even point shifts dramatically based on home appreciation rates:
| Home Appreciation Rate | Break-Even Point | Rent Advantage at 5 Years |
|---|---|---|
| 1% | Never (buy loses) | $98,000+ |
| 2% | 9-10 years | $67,000 |
| 3% | 6-7 years | $36,000 |
| 4% | 4-5 years | $5,000 |
| 5% | 3-4 years | Buy wins by $26,000 |
*Based on $350K home, 20% down, 7% mortgage, $2,000 starting rent. “Rent advantage” shows how much wealthier the renter is at 5 years; negative means buyer is ahead.
The Transaction Cost Problem
One of the most underappreciated factors in the rent vs. buy decision is the sheer cost of real estate transactions. Buying and selling a home isn’t free—it’s extraordinarily expensive.
Buying Costs (2-5%)
Loan origination fees, appraisal, title insurance, inspection, recording fees, attorney fees (in some states). On a $350K home: $7,000-17,500.
Selling Costs (6-8%)
Agent commissions (5-6%), transfer taxes, staging, repairs, closing costs. On a $400K sale: $24,000-32,000.
Round-Trip Total (8-12%)
Buy at $350K, sell at $400K, lose $35,000-50,000 in transaction costs. That’s money that never builds equity.
The Short-Term Trap
If you sell after 3 years, transaction costs alone could exceed all the equity you built—even if home prices rose 10%.
Two Investors, Two Paths
Meet Maya and Derek. Both have $70,000 saved and earn $120,000/year in the same city. They make different choices.
Maya: The 10-Year Buyer
- • Buys a $350K home with 20% down
- • Plans to stay at least 10 years
- • Refinances when rates drop to 5.5%
- • Home appreciates 3%/year on average
Net wealth after 10 years:
$247,000
Equity + appreciation − all costs
Derek: The Strategic Renter
- • Rents at $2,000/month
- • Invests $70K down payment in index funds
- • Invests the monthly savings (early years)
- • Relocates twice for career advancement
Net wealth after 10 years:
$189,000
Investment portfolio − rent paid
Maya comes out ahead financially—but Derek’s relocations increased his salary by 40% over the decade. The “right” choice depends on far more than the spreadsheet.
What It Means for You — When Buying Wins (and When It Doesn't)
The rent vs. buy decision comes down to four variables you can estimate and one big unknown you can’t. Understanding what you control—and what you’re betting on—is the key to making a decision you won’t regret.
The Four Levers You Control
1. Time Horizon
This is the dominant variable. If you’re confident you’ll stay 7+ years, buying usually wins. If you might move in 3 years, renting almost always wins. Be honest about your actual likelihood of staying.
2. Local Rent-to-Price Ratio
Divide annual rent by purchase price. Above 5% (rent is cheap relative to prices) favors renting. Below 4% (rent is expensive relative to prices) favors buying. Check this ratio in your specific neighborhood.
3. Your Alternative Return
If you rent, what return will your down payment earn? Conservative investors (3-4%) will see buying win sooner. Aggressive investors with higher expected returns (6-7%) strengthen the rent case.
4. Your Down Payment Size
A larger down payment means more money not invested elsewhere—a higher opportunity cost. It also means lower monthly payments and no PMI. The sweet spot depends on your investment returns and local prices.
Reality Check: The Tax Benefit Myth
Before 2017, the mortgage interest deduction was a significant benefit of homeownership. The Tax Cuts and Jobs Act changed that calculus dramatically for most buyers.
The Post-2017 Reality
The standard deduction nearly doubled in 2017 to $14,600 (single) or $29,200 (married filing jointly) in 2024. To benefit from the mortgage interest deduction, your itemized deductions must exceed these thresholds. For most homeowners with mortgages under $500K, they don’t—meaning the mortgage interest deduction provides zero tax benefit. Don’t factor in tax savings unless you’ve confirmed you’ll actually itemize.
What If You’re Unsure About Your Timeline?
Uncertainty about how long you’ll stay is itself valuable information. If you can’t confidently say “I’ll be here at least 5 years,” that uncertainty is a strong argument for renting. Here’s why:
The asymmetry of outcomes matters. If you buy and end up staying 10 years, you probably win by $50,000-100,000. If you buy and have to move after 2 years, you could easily lose $40,000-60,000. Renting protects you from the catastrophic downside while giving up some of the upside—a reasonable trade when you’re uncertain.
Pro Tip
Run the calculation twice: once with your “expected” timeline and once with a “forced early sale” scenario (job loss, divorce, relocation). If buying still makes sense in the worst-case scenario, it’s a safer bet. If buying only works if everything goes perfectly, renting may be wiser.
The Non-Financial Factors
The spreadsheet only tells part of the story. Some things don’t have dollar values:
Favors Renting
- • Career mobility and relocation flexibility
- • Freedom from maintenance responsibility
- • Lower financial stress and emergency risk
- • Easier to “right-size” as life changes
Favors Buying
- • Stability and roots in a community
- • Freedom to customize and renovate
- • Forced savings through mortgage payments
- • Protection from rent increases and eviction
The Bottom Line
If you’re staying 7+ years in a market with reasonable price-to-rent ratios, buying typically wins financially—but not by as much as you might think. If your timeline is shorter or uncertain, renting isn’t “throwing money away”—it’s buying flexibility and avoiding the substantial risks of an early sale. Run the numbers for your specific situation before letting cultural assumptions make the decision for you.
Try It Out — Run Your Own Comparison
The examples in this article use national averages, but your decision depends on your local market, your timeline, and your financial situation. Use the calculator below to run the numbers with your actual inputs and see which path builds more wealth over your expected time horizon.
Quick Start Calculator
Down payment: $70,000 — monthly P&I: $1,770
Over 7 Years
$55,188
Estimated advantage of buying
Total Cost of Renting
$235,925
Net Cost of Buying
$180,737
Home Equity Built
$177,290
Cumulative Cost Comparison
Compares total renting cost (including opportunity cost of down payment) against net buying cost over time.
What to Look For in the Results
Total Cost of Renting
The sum of all rent payments, renter’s insurance, and the opportunity cost of equity not built—offset by investment gains on your down payment.
Total Cost of Buying
All mortgage payments, taxes, insurance, maintenance, and transaction costs—offset by equity built and home appreciation captured.
Net Wealth Difference
The bottom line: how much wealthier (or poorer) you’ll be choosing one path over the other at the end of your timeline.
Break-Even Year
The year when buying starts to win. If this is longer than your expected stay, renting is likely the better financial choice.
This calculator provides estimates for educational purposes only. Actual costs will vary based on market conditions, interest rates, local taxes, and other factors. Consult with a financial advisor and real estate professional before making major housing decisions.
Run the Full Analysis
The interactive calculator above is a quick-start version. The full tool offers more inputs, detailed breakdowns, data tables, and CSV export.
Open Full Calculator